Insights / Battery-electric trucks · Sep 2024
Diesel, HVO or battery-electric? Decarbonising long-haul trucking in Germany
My master's thesis compared the five-year cost and life-cycle emissions of a 40-tonne long-haul truck in Germany running on diesel, HVO or electricity. HVO cuts emissions by 78% for about €38 per tonne. Battery-electric trucks look cheaper on paper until you count the payload their battery takes away.
- HVO emissions vs diesel
- −78%
- HVO cost per tonne avoided
- €38
- Battery-electric cost, same freight
- +31%
Heavy-duty vehicles cause around 30% of road transport emissions in the EU, and Germany runs the second-largest truck fleet in the Union. Long-haul freight is also the hardest segment to decarbonise: trucks drive far, carry heavy loads and run on thin margins.
My master’s thesis at ESCP Business School asked a practical question: which energy should a German company running long-haul trucks switch to today, judged on both cost and emissions? I compared three options for a 40-tonne tractor-trailer over a five-year ownership period: conventional diesel (B7), hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO, used as a drop-in fuel in the same truck) and battery-electric.
How the comparison works
Two models run side by side on the same truck and the same duty cycle:
- Total cost of ownership (TCO): purchase price net of resale, battery, financing, insurance, vehicle tax, motorway toll, maintenance, energy and charging or fuelling infrastructure.
- Life-cycle assessment (LCA): cradle-to-grave greenhouse-gas emissions from building the vehicle and battery, the infrastructure, maintenance, and the energy itself (well-to-wheel).
The base case is a Euro VI truck driving 119,000 km a year, with a daily range of up to 500 km and a return to the depot each night. Diesel costs €1.37 per litre, HVO €0.12 more, and electricity €0.20 per kWh. The battery-electric truck carries 900 kWh of batteries at €221 per kWh, and the grid electricity it uses has a carbon intensity of 330 g CO₂e per kWh.
The cost nobody puts on the price tag: payload
A 40-tonne limit applies to every truck. Batteries are heavy, so every tonne of battery is a tonne of freight that stays behind.
Most TCO studies compare one truck with one truck. That flatters the electric truck, because a logistics company does not sell truck-kilometres; it sells tonne-kilometres. So I ran every result twice: once per truck, and once payload-normalised, with the cost and emissions of the extra 0.32 trucks needed to move the same freight.
The electric truck saves heavily on energy (−€103k), on toll and vehicle tax (−€87k, thanks to Germany’s CO₂-based truck toll) and on maintenance. But its battery alone adds €158k, more than the rest of the vehicle. Compared truck for truck, the savings almost exactly cancel the battery: the electric truck comes out 0.4% cheaper than diesel. Normalised for payload, it is 31% more expensive. HVO costs 3.3% more than diesel, almost all of it the fuel premium.
On emissions, HVO wins clearly: 78% below diesel, with no change to the truck or the filling station. The electric truck cuts 44% truck for truck, but only 26% once payload is counted, because the extra trucks and their batteries have to be built and powered too.
This is the number a fleet manager can act on. HVO avoids a tonne of CO₂ for about €38, less than the €45 CO₂ price Germany already charged on diesel in 2024. The payload-normalised electric truck pays €1,087 per tonne, almost thirty times as much. Compared truck for truck, it saves money and emissions at the same time, which is why the payload question decides the answer.
What would make battery-electric the cleaner option?
The electric truck’s emissions depend on the grid that charges it. Move the cursor across the chart to see its life-cycle emissions at different grid carbon intensities.
Battery-electric emissions depend on the grid
Life-cycle emissions per truck over five years, tonnes CO₂e, by carbon intensity of the electricity used
Carbon intensity of the electricity used, g CO₂e per kWh
Data table
| Carbon intensity of the electricity used, g CO₂e per kWh | Battery-electric, same freight | Diesel truck | HVO truck |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 211 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 50 | 265 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 100 | 320 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 150 | 374 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 200 | 428 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 250 | 482 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 300 | 537 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 350 | 591 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 400 | 645 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 450 | 700 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 500 | 754 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 550 | 808 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 600 | 863 t | 767 t | 166 t |
Carbon intensity of the electricity used, g CO₂e per kWh
Data table
| Carbon intensity of the electricity used, g CO₂e per kWh | Battery-electric, one truck | Diesel truck | HVO truck |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 160 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 50 | 201 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 100 | 242 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 150 | 283 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 200 | 324 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 250 | 365 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 300 | 406 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 350 | 447 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 400 | 488 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 450 | 529 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 500 | 570 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 550 | 611 t | 767 t | 166 t |
| 600 | 653 t | 767 t | 166 t |
Linear in the grid's carbon intensity; all other inputs as in the base case.
Source Katam (2024), master's thesis, ESCP Business School, LCA sensitivity analysis
Two thresholds stand out:
- Compared with diesel, the payload-normalised electric truck is cleaner on any grid below about 510 g CO₂e per kWh, well above the 330 g of the base case.
- Compared with HVO, it never catches up while payload is lost: even on a zero-carbon grid it emits 211 t against HVO’s 166 t, because of battery production and the extra trucks. Truck for truck, it beats HVO only on a grid below about 8 g per kWh.
What this means for fleet operators
HVO is the immediate lever. It runs in existing Euro VI engines, uses existing filling stations and needs no capital. The limits are supply and price: HVO depends on waste oils and fats, and aviation and shipping compete for the same feedstocks.
Battery-electric is the long-term bet, and payload is the variable to watch. Lighter batteries with higher energy density, cheaper cells and depot charging that fits the duty cycle all move the electric truck towards parity. Germany’s CO₂-based truck toll already narrows the cost gap.
A phased approach follows: switch existing diesel trucks to HVO now, and electrify the routes where payload is not the binding constraint first.
Limits of the analysis
The study uses 2024 prices and a five-year ownership period, the most common in the market. It covers the short-range duty cycle that most fleets run. Battery second life and recycling credits were excluded because their future value is uncertain, and HVO feedstock was assumed to come from waste rather than crops.